Iraqi cleric Mahmoud al-Sarkhi deepens intra-Shia dispute | Politics News

Baghdad, Iraq – A mosque pulled down by tractors, indignant protesters setting buildings on fireplace, and police arrests: regardless of their comparatively small-scale, current occasions throughout a couple of cities in Iraq have been sufficient to startle the nation during the last month, and all have been linked to a controversial Muslim scholar – Mahmoud al-Sarkhi.

The set off within the newest spherical of what has change into an more and more tense intra-Shia leaders’ dispute was an in any other case uneventful Friday sermon in early April, when Ali Masoudi, a consultant of al-Sarkhi, who’s a former scholar of the late outstanding Shia scholar Mohammad Sadiq al-Sadr, demanded the demolition of shrines, or graves of Shia imams, throughout Iraq.

“We should always observe the teachings of the Prophet [Muhammed] and Imam Ali and never construct any constructions on the graves,” Masoudi passionately instructed a bunch of individuals attending the sermon.

The demand was unsurprisingly dismissed by the vast majority of Iraqi Shia Muslims, however then got here the fiery response: livid protesters, principally supporters of Muslim chief Moqtada al-Sadr, the son of Sadiq al-Sadr and presently the largest political participant in Iraq, took to the streets and burned down a few of al-Sarkhi’s places of work in numerous cities, together with Babil, Karbala, and Basra.

The Iraqi safety forces quickly arrested numerous al-Sarkhi’s followers. Babil governorate, the place al-Sarkhi’s motion is predicated, promptly moved to shut all the chief’s places of work, and one in all al-Sarkhi’s mosques within the governorate was torn down.

Moqtada al-Sadr himself additionally issued a warning to al-Sarkhi that until the scholar disavowed the consultant who known as for the destruction of the shrines, he would resort to “authorized and customary strategies”, in line with a observe al-Sadr posted on Twitter, though it’s unclear whether or not al-Sadr would observe via along with his threats.

Within the weeks following the controversial sermon, al-Sarkhi has change into the topic of widespread discussions in Iraq, igniting debates on his ideology and what threats he may pose to the now total steady Iraqi safety.

Regardless of the criticism in direction of al-Sarkhi’s demand to demolish graves, some specialists are voicing their concern over how the federal government’s response has run the danger of additional stoking violence and battle in a deeply scarred nation.

“The state has been reactive as a substitute of proactive over the previous few years, and none of [the reactions were] about taking the initiative to struggle sectarianism,” Ruba Ali al-Hassani, a UK-based sociologist who research Iraq, instructed Al Jazeera. “As an alternative of launching arrests of al-Sarkhi’s individuals, there ought to have been extra restorative and correctional efforts.”

For al-Sarkhi, this isn’t the primary time he managed to seize consideration. This time, nonetheless, it coincided with a chaotic authorities formation course of that has been definitively stalled by intra-Shia political division.

A supporter of Sheikh Mahmoud al-Hassani al-Sarkhi is arrested following clashes in Karbala [Mohammed Sawaf/AFP]

“He realises that Shias, typically, are passing via a really chaotic interval with low confidence in all spiritual political events and actions,” Munqith M Dagher, the founding father of the Iraq-based Unbiased Institute of Administration and Civil Society Research, instructed Al Jazeera. “Accordingly, that is the very best time to search out extra followers who’re hating the present gamers and welcome any totally different voices.”

Al-Sarkhi and his motion didn’t reply to Al Jazeera’s request for remark.


A determine who first emerged following the United States-led invasion of Iraq in 2003, al-Sarkhi had a reasonably low profile and would periodically re-emerge within the public discourse with at instances controversial claims, and generally violent clashes with both US or Iraqi safety forces.

Initially combating alongside the once-formidable Mehdi Military, a now-disbanded paramilitary group led by Moqtada al-Sadr, towards the US forces through the early days of the Iraq battle, al-Sarkhi quickly parted methods with al-Sadr.

Constructing on his staunch resistance in direction of each American and Iranian affect in Iraq, al-Sarkhi has thus far accrued a modest following within the tens of hundreds.

“In contrast to Moqtada, who modifications his place each 5 days, al-Sarkhi has remained dedicated to rejecting the US and Iranian affect in our nation,” Hassan, an al-Sarkhi follower dwelling in Karbala instructed Al Jazeera, referring to the generally altering nature of Moqtada al-Sadr’s political stances.

“He might have some opinions that I don’t fully agree with, however I believe he’s the one who really cares about Iraq and the individuals,” he added.

Al-Sarkhi has repeatedly voiced his opposition to Iranian affect in Iraq. Throughout Iraq’s 2019 mass demonstrations, for instance, al-Sarkhi’s motion reportedly inspired protesters to set fireplace to the Iranian consulate in Karbala, which turned out to be some of the dramatic nights of all the protests.

He even rejected Ali al-Sistani, essentially the most revered scholar amongst Iraqi Shia Muslims, primarily based on his declare that al-Sistani had an excessive amount of Iranian affect behind him. Nonetheless, some specialists say his rejection of Iran has typically overstepped its boundary.

“He argues that Iran tried to form the Shia public discourse and threaten nationwide safety in Iraq,” al-Hassani stated. “Nonetheless, he overreaches by claiming that there isn’t any public Shia discourse in Iraq and that it was completely Iranian.”

Negotiate with ISIL?

Al-Sarkhi has additionally confronted criticism for his position through the rise of ISIL (ISIS) in 2014. On the time, al-Sistani had issued a fatwa, a spiritual decree, to name on all in a position Iraqis to take up arms to struggle towards the armed group that seized an unlimited swath of land in Iraq and neighbouring Syria.

To most individuals’s shock, al-Sarkhi refused to reply the fatwa, and as a substitute known as for conversations and negotiations with ISIL, regardless of the crimes dedicated by the group, and the failure of diplomatic efforts to succeed in out to them.

“Even now, many are questioning his stance in direction of ISIS,” al-Hassani stated. “Whilst somebody who works on peacebuilding, I wouldn’t agree to barter with ISIS when the group was happening a killing rampage.”

His controversial claims, nonetheless, hardly ever brought about any large points to Iraqi safety and, in line with specialists and customary Iraqis who spoke with Al Jazeera, his comparatively small following will unlikely represent an precise menace sooner or later, regardless of the controversy generated not too long ago.

“You hear about him such as you hear about some clowns on TV, and I believe the explanation why persons are protesting is as a result of they want one thing to vent their anger in direction of the present political mess in Iraq,” Ali Saleem, a Baghdad resident, instructed Al Jazeera.

“I don’t assume it’s due to how necessary al-Sarkhi is.”